|
Summary
The literature indicates that most
neonates born to mothers in methadone maintenance treatment will have
withdrawal symptoms and are likely to need medical intervention.
However, studies are contradictory: frequency of needed
treatment varies widely between studies. Some indicate that withdrawal
is dose-related, others that it is not -- not even if the mother is on
a very high dosage of methadone. These findings do not make sense. A
more or less linear correlation between maternal methadone dosage and
likelihood of significant withdrawal would be expected.
There are indications that other factors are more
important than methadone dosage. For instance, there appears to be a
correlation between NAS and other drug use, particularly
benzodiazepines and nicotine, and there is a correlation with
gestational age with premature babies having fewer withdrawal symptoms.
My retrospective study (exclusively based on the
mother's reports) seems to show that the neonatal abstinence syndrome
is most closely related to maternal stress due to uncertainties and
fears. Mothers who participated well in offered services, who
handled general stress and the stress of anticipated childbirth well,
were likely to have a baby with only minor or no appreciable neonatal
withdrawal symptoms.
Introduction
1.
Medication withdrawal
Opioid withdrawal is primarily a stress
syndrome. Medication withdrawal is generally not correlated to
blood levels but to the mind's expectation of relief from
stress. Opiate, tranquilizer and alcohol addicts get, thanks
to the drug use, regularly relief from stress. The mind, i.e. the central
nervous system (CNS), develops a tolerance, allowing essentially normal
functioning with the drug, but the CNS also expects the relaxing drug
action and develops rhythms that incorporate the drug action at
specific receptor sites. When the expected relief does not come,
increasing stress symptoms occur; however these are typically
vacillating. The worst withdrawal typically occurs long after the
medication has become undetectable in blood level
measurements. Alcohol addicts may work regularly while sober
during the day but go into mild withdrawal if there is no new
alcohol intake in the evening. Withdrawal is much worse on the second
evening without alcohol. Opioid maintenance patients who
previously used drugs mainly in the evening usually suffer most craving
and withdrawal-like symptoms in the evening while in treatment with a
long-acting opioid medication.
Usually, these drug withdrawal symptoms are easily
influenced. Placebo drugs and false beliefs can greatly increase or
decrease withdrawal symptoms. When patients
believe their methadone dosage has been decreased, they may go
into withdrawal, while forgetting the medication altogether is easily
tolerated, e.g.
during vacation in unfamiliar settings. When introduced, it
was thought that heroin, as compared to morphine, has only minimal or
no withdrawal symptoms. The same was thought of
benzodiazepines, as compared to barbiturates, oral methadone, as
compared to heroin and opioid pain medications, and most recently, the
same myth applied to sublingual buprenorphine.
Drugs suppressing the stress reaction of
the CNS, such as clonidine, propanolol and amitriptyline, or a slow
taper of an opioid medication, considerably reduce opiate withdrawal
symptoms. Placebo drugs and meditation/prayer may also work.
2.
Pregnancy and stress
During pregnancy, stress may be significant. The
mother's stress hormones influence fetal development. For
instance, in the late first trimester, when the male fetal brain is
supposed to be 'masculinized', the mother's stress hormones may
interfere with this process, leading in a male fetus to a person with
male body but essentially female brain and later development of primary
homosexuality (births during World War II; rat studies1).
Many more recent studies indicate that major
stress in the pregnant women may have adverse effects on the fetus,
including stress reactivity in the newborn and insomnia2.
3.
Neonatal withdrawal syndrome
The literature indicates that withdrawal symptoms
in infants born to mothers on methadone maintenance are the
rule rather than the exception (up to 90% with 50-75% needing treatment3,
62-74% with length of treatment ranging from 7-49 days. These results
are reportedly comparable with results reported at other institutions4).
In addition, there is an
association between maternal methadone use, pre-term births and small
infants. In accordance with some studies, the frequency of
neonatal withdrawal symptoms from methadone correlates poorly with
methadone dosage at all dosage levels5. My
observation was that at
least in lower dosage range, neonatal abstinence symptoms were
unpredictable while high dosage maintenance had a much higher rate of
withdrawal. Some studies indicate that likelihood of
withdrawal is closely related with maternal methadone
dosage6. However, one study indicates
that even in high
dosage methadone maintenance, there is no correlation between dosage
and observed withdrawal symptoms in the newborn. These
findings do not make sense: a more or less linear correlation
between
maternal methadone dosage and likelihood of significant withdrawal
would be expected. One study indicated that later gestational
age (37 weeks or more) and concomitant benzodiazepine use were
associated with the need for longer treatment of neonatal withdrawal
symptoms6. A Swiss study showed the
detrimental effect of
polydrug use while pregnant and on methadone maintenance7.
In my retrospective study, I did not look closely at nicotine and other
drug use; however, there appeared to be a correlation between
other drug use, including nicotine, non-participation in our services
and withdrawal in the newborn.
Patients
Involved in Retrospective Study
All births to patients at this clinic in the years
2006-2009 are included. All patients were in methadone
treatment either when they became pregnant or they started treatment in
early pregnancy (one patient
diagnosed to be pregnant on admission; one transferred to our clinic
very late in pregnancy). To our knowledge, none of the
pregnancies were planned. There were eleven Anglo women and
one Latin woman who had two children during this time. All
but one were in their late twenties and thirties, and most had given
birth previously. Regarding outcomes, no significant
difference between
primipara and multipara were observed, however the youngest patient did
most poorly. To my knowledge, most patients planned to
breastfeed, but hospital routines, CPS involvement, etc.
created too much stress during the postnatal period for most to do
this. Almost all bottle fed their newborns mostly or
exclusively. All patients had ready
access to individual counseling. A few did not take advantage of what
the clinic offered, and for a few of the patients counseling was
primarily crisis-oriented
(involvement with Child Protective Services, family conflicts, legal
problems, and one case with a short jail stay and temporary
homelessness). The youngest women had ongoing complaints
about aches, pains, painful restless leg syndrome, and panic
attack. The two women who had most problems had
relapses:
temporarily or intermittent severe drug abuse. Several
patients had lapses (on one or few occasions impulsive one-time
use) and/or some continued smoking. One baby was
shortly icteric. Otherwise we have no information about any baby having
abnormalities or needing treatment other than for NAS.
Methadone
Maintenance & Pregnancy: Counseling & Group
Teaching
Pregnancies in methadone maintenance patients are
usually
stressful. They are rarely planned even though often
welcomed. However, often there is then the consequent fears
of disapproval by
relatives and friends, of intervention by Child Protective Services and
the fear of childbirth itself. Patients on methadone maintenance are
usually more sensitive to pain than average, and opioid pain
medications
have little effect unless given in much larger dosage than usual (this
is rarely understood by physicians). In addition, clinics for
indigent obstetric patients are rarely conducive to making women feel
cared for. Obviously, the high level of stress often leads to
lapsing thoughts and behaviors and the fear of relapse is in itself a
stress factor.
In counseling pregnant
methadone maintenance patients, our goal has been to minimize stress
during pregnancies in order to improve our patients' birth experiences
while
decreasing the rate of complications. To improve these
services, I started to facilitate educational pregnancy groups.
Patients were encouraged to start in the first
trimester. Group teaching included autogenic training (AT),
specific self-hypnotic
techniques, education about childbirth, education regarding
breast-feeding and discussions about dealing with institutions
(hospitals, child protective services). Most important was
the practice of AT which has been much used in Europe for many
conditions, and techniques to raise pain tolerance and modify/decrease
pain perception. AT is used to go very quickly into a deeply
relaxed state, starting with comfortable heaviness and warmth in
dominant hand and letting the feeling quickly spread over the whole
body. Then AT steps three to five may be utilized and
self-hypnotic suggestions may be added. Patients are also
taught that it is always important to stay in the present, to go into
meditative state between contractions, and focus on the moment during
contractions.
Results
Benefits of
counseling and group teaching
The result of this study
indicates mothers who were most involved
in offered services reported relatively good birth experiences (all
participating patients who had given birth previously
reported the
present birth experience was better than the previous one(s) and that
the techniques acquired were helpful). In this sense the
counseling and groups fulfilled their originally intended
purpose. However, we were not very successful in our
encouragements to breastfeed their infants. Regarding the
neonatal abstinence syndrome: in our small group, newborns of
patients who participated in our childbirth preparation counseling and
learned relaxation/meditation techniques had much less neonatal
abstinence symptoms than statistically expected. In addition,
the only premature baby (<37weeks) in that group was induced due
to maternal increase in blood pressure (two 42 weeks, two 40 weeks, two
38 weeks, one 36 weeks.)
Data:
Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome (NAS) Data -
Summary of 13 births 2006-2009
| Time in
treatment while pregnant |
Treatment involvement
(judged by staff) |
Daily methadone dose |
Reported
intensity/duration of withdrawal symptoms |
Gestational age |
Type of birth |
Infant descriptive data |
Comments |
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+
(minimal counseling) |
155mg |
significant |
approximately
37 weeks |
emergency
C-section |
No
data |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
++
(mostly individual;
few groups) |
73mg |
none |
40
weeks |
vaginal
birth, induced |
female;
6lbs., 8oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+
(much stress); groups |
140mg |
few
weeks |
approximately
37 weeks |
vaginal
birth |
male;
6lbs., 3oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
++
(much stress); groups; individual |
130mg |
minor;
for a few days |
40.5
weeks |
vaginal
birth |
female;
7lbs., 12 oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
++ (much
stress); groups; individual |
60mg |
none |
38
weeks |
vaginal
birth, induced |
male,
21", 6lbs., 11oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+ (c/o
pain & RLS*
while pregnant)
|
150mg |
5-6
weeks |
37
weeks |
vaginal
birth |
no
data |
opiate
and benzodiazepine abuse |
| 2
1/2 weeks |
+
(little time for counseling or groups) |
40mg |
minor;
for a few days |
38
weeks |
vaginal
birth |
male;
7lbs., 1 oz.
|
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+
(late few groups) |
164mg |
significant |
approximately
35 weeks |
reportedly
vaginal birth |
male;
4lbs., 4oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+
(counseling crisis-oriented) |
114mg |
few
weeks |
approximately
36 weeks |
C-section
(planned abortion) |
|
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+++
(stress), pregnancy groups, individual |
70mg |
minor
for a few days |
approximately
36 weeksa |
vaginal
birth, induced |
male;
18", 5lbs., 5oz.
|
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+++
(stress), pregnancy groups, individual |
100mg |
noneb |
42
weeks |
vaginal
birth |
female;
8lbs., 8oz. |
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+++
(stress), pregnancy groups, individual |
177mg |
none |
38
weeks |
vaginal
birth |
female;
7lbs., 13oz.
(breast fed)
|
|
| Throughout
pregnancy |
+++
(stress), pregnancy groups, individual |
22mg |
nonec |
possibly
42 weeks |
vaginal
birth |
male;
20"
7lbs., 2oz.
(jaundice)
|
|
* RLS = Restless Leg Syndrome
a = Induced, maternal increase in blood pressure
b = The mother reports that the baby was kept a few weeks in hospital
for observation but did not need treatment
c = Newborn had mild jaundice. It was reportedly given small dosages of
methadone preventively for four weeks even though no withdrawal
symptoms were observed/reported
Number of patients by treatment
involvement (as judged
by
staff):
4
+++ 3
++ 2
+ 4 (+)
Number of patients by mother's dosage of methadone (at time of
birth): 6
>120mg 5
60-120mg 2 <60mg
Number of patients by, by mother reported, withdrawal symptoms (NAS): 5 none 3
minor 4 few
wks 1 >1mo
Patients with Good Treatment Participation
| Involvement
in treatment |
Neonatal
withdrawal |
Daily
methadone dosage |
Gestational
age in weeks |
Weight |
| +++ |
+
(minor, few days) |
70mg |
36 weeksa |
5
lbs.
5 oz. |
| +++ |
0
(none?)b |
100mg |
42
weeks |
8
lbs.
8 oz. |
| +++ |
0
(none) |
177mg |
38
weeks |
7
lbs.
13 oz. |
| +++ |
0
(none?)c |
22mg |
42
weeks(?) |
--
|
| ++ |
0
(none) |
73mg |
40
weeks |
6
lbs.
8 oz. |
| ++ |
+ (minor, few days)
|
130mg |
40.5 |
7
lbs.
12 oz. |
| ++ |
0
(none) |
60mg |
38
weeks |
6
lbs.
11 oz. |
Patients with Low Treatment Participation
Involvement
in treatment
|
Neonatal
withdrawal |
Daily
methadone dosage |
Gestational
age in weeks |
Weight |
| + |
++
(few weeks) |
140mg |
37
weeks |
7
lbs.
13 oz. |
| + |
++
(few weeks) |
114mg |
36
weeks |
--
|
| (+) |
++
(significant) |
155mg |
37
weeks |
-- |
| (+) |
+++
5-6 weeks |
150mg |
37
weeks |
-- |
| (+) |
+
(minor, few days) |
40mg |
38
weeks |
7
lbs.
1 oz. |
| (+) |
++
(significant) |
164mg |
35
weeks |
5
lbs.
5 oz. |
a = Induced, maternal increase in blood pressure
b = The mother reports that the baby was kept a few weeks in hospital
for observation but did not need treatment
c = Newborn had mild jaundice. It was reportedly given small dosages of
methadone preventively for four weeks even though no withdrawal
symptoms were observed/reported
Conclusions
Pregnancy counseling at the clinic started to improve our patients'
birth experiences. This indicates that good childbirth preparation and
learning stress/pain management techniques improved outcomes for the
neonates. There were much fewer neonatal withdrawal symptoms, generally
shorter hospital stays, and less premature births. However, this was
neither a blind nor prospective study and the numbers are small. It may
be considered "good anecdotal evidence".
Appendix
Subjects to be covered in pregnancy groups, as feasible:
-
methadone (or buprenorphine) o. k (generally: do not switch from one to
the other during pregnancy).; how to talk to family
- ask for TH dose if too nauseated to take dose and/or stay here after
taking it
- dose decreases mid trimester o.k.
- abortion o.k. (particularly if malformation)
- smoking/nicotine (stop or at least decrease)
- benzodiazepine use (decrease and stop)
- antidepressant/mood stabilizer use
- measures and medications for nausea
- CPS issues
- Urine drug screens (refuse if using and discuss lapse with case
manager)
- circumcision (not recommended)
- healthy lifestyle, diet, walking after carbohydrate meal (diabetes
prevention)
-
stress management, cognitive (What am I afraid of? What are conflicts
about? Is it my problem? How much time do I have to decide?
What
is the worst case scenario? "I'm bigger than the problem.")
- autogenic training (AT)
- pain in general: pain stimuli reach brain, mind "screams no" or
accepts sensation (sometimes welcomes it, e.g. in
masochism, when self-injecting drug, in self-injurious
behaviors to relieve mental pain); sensitization (increased fear after
painful experience, "was much worse than expected" "I'd rather die than
live through such pain again") and desensitization (more
self-confidence, "I lived through it", "I'm proud of how I handled that
pain", often "the result was worth the pain", etc.)
- self-hypnotic techniques
-
birth process; physiology and anatomy; stages; relaxing between
contractions; always staying in moment - content of our "surgery
letter": for pain, considerably more methadone best, dosing every 8-12
hours; no agonist-antagonist medications (Nubain, Stadol, Talwin,
Buprenex, etc.)
- epidural
- emergency and planned C-section
- withdrawal symptoms in newborn, mangment
- breast feeding; as much physical contact with newborn as
possible
References
1 Irenäus Eible-Eibeseldt: Die Biologie des menschlichen
Verhaltens, 4. Auflage 1997, p.358f
2
a) http://cpj.sagepub.com/content/49/2/158.abstract CLIN PEDIATR
February 2010 vol. 49 no. 2 158-165 Perceived Maternal Stress During
Pregnancy and Its Relation to Infant Stress Reactivity at 2 Days and 10
Months of Postnatal Life Eman Leung et al. [Conclusion. These
preliminary findings suggest that maternal stress during pregnancy may
negatively affect neonatal stress reactivity within 24 to 48 hours
after birth, and these influences may persist through the first year of
postnatal life.]
b)
www.womensmentalhealth.org/.../maternal-stress-during-pregnancy-linked-to-infant-sleep-problems
MGH Center for Women’s Mental Health Maternal Stress During Pregnancy
Linked to Infant Sleep Problems Published: July 26, 2008
c) J
Psychiatry Neurosci.
2008 January; 33(1): 10–16. Relation of maternal stress during
pregnancy to symptom severity and response to treatment in children
with ADHD Natalie Grizenko, et
al
d)
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/08/080820194845.htm Science Daily (Aug.
21, 2008) Acute Maternal Stress During Pregnancy Linked To Development
Of Schizophrenia
e)
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2007/may/31/childrensservices.medicineandhealth
"Mother's stress harms foetus, research shows - Brain development may
suffer as early as 17 weeks · Charity urges supportive environment in
pregnancy," Lucy Ward, social affairs correspondent The Guardian,
Thursday 31 May 2007
f)
http://www.jhsph.edu/publichealthnews/press_releases/2006/dipietro_stress.html
May 17, 2006 Mild Maternal Stress May Actually Help Children
Mature
3 www.bsuh.nhs.uk/EasySiteWeb/GatewayLink.aspx?alId=52020
TMBU PROTOCOL – August 2006 NEONATAL DRUG WITHDRAWAL
4 American
journal of obstetrics and gynecology
“Predicting length of treatment for neonatal abstinence syndrome in
methadone exposed neonates.” Volume 199, Issue 4, October 2008, Pages
396.e1-396.e7 DOI: 10.1016/j.ajog.2008.06.088 Neil S SELIGMAN, et
al
5 a) American
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (2005) 193, 606-10
"High-dose methadone maintenance in pregnancy: Maternal and neonatal
outcomes," John J. McCarthy, et
al
b) The Journal
of Pediatrics, "Relationship between Maternal Methadone
Dose at Delivery and Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome," Neil S. Seligman, et al Available
online 15 May 2010
6 Obstetrics
& Gynecology:
December 2002 - Volume 100 - Issue 6 - p 1244-1249 "Original Research
Relationship Between Maternal Methadone Dosage and Neonatal Withdrawal"
Dashe, Jodi S., et al
7 Acta Obstet Gynecol
Scand
2005: 84: 145--150 "Methadone maintenance program in pregnancy in a
Swiss perinatal center (II): neonatal outcome and social resources"
ROMAINE ARLETTAZ, et al
From the Clinic of Neonatology and Department of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Zurich University Hospital, Switzerland.
|